I was extremely excited when I saw the preview for the new Sci-Fi channel miniseries Tin Man this fall. Being a fan of the original Wizard of Oz books and movie, Wicked by Gregory Maguire and the musical Wicked, I was looking forward to a new spin on the same story of Oz. I was hesitant about it being on the SciFi channel, considering their pension for making the worst movies in history. However, the preview looked rather promising, with an interesting cast including Richard Dreyfuss, Zooey Deschanel and Alan Cumming. So, when I sat down with my friends on Sunday to watch the premiere 2-hour episode I was deeply disappointed, and here is why.
The miniseries was not what was portrayed in the preview: a world of vivid color and magical things with excellent performances. The story starts in Kansas, per usual, with a girl named D.G. (Zooey Deschanel) living a very normal life with her overly normal parents. Then she starts having dreams. He parents freak and tell her a storm is coming and she has to return. At the same time, we meet an evil sorceress who looks like she was kicked out of a bad LARP session. She sends her cronies, large men in black leather trench coats oddly reminiscent of Nazis, to go catch D.G. by way of travel storm. This part was kind of cool because the cronies appear in bolts of lightning during the classic tornado part. I want to travel by tornado lightning. So cool! Sorry, sidebar. So after an elaborate chase scene, and dad getting shot in the leg, the parents push D.G. off the roof into the tornado! Talk about parental affection. Also kind of cool ‘cause I kind of want to ride a tornado too.
So we find out eventually that D.G.’s parents aren’t really her parents, surprise, but androids sent to watch over her after her sister sucked the life out of her and her mother gave here part of her life to reanimate her. Convoluted anyone? We meet the Scarecrow character, named Glitch (Alan Cummings), who is also an android with part of his brain removed through a zippered opening in his head. The Cowardly Lion is found in a trap set by Predators that spit acid or something. He isn’t really a lion, but a psychic hippie with long hair, beard, shaggy clothes and bare feet included. The Tin Man is actually an ex police office for the wizard of the O.Z., the Outer Zone, who was trapped in a tin box and forced to watch his family be tortured for 20 years or something. He’s a little odd to say the least. The characters and plots are far too convoluted and try too hard to fit in with current events and are overly concerned with being politically correct. The fact that Zooey Deschanel looks more dazed than Lindsay Lohan also makes it rather painful to watch. The dialogue was unnatural and forced, making it hard to watch and harder to understand. The complexities of the story were over explained through flashbacks in hazy filters, literally recounting what had happened no more than 30 minutes ago. Truly a Sci-Fi miniseries.
Now there were some rather enjoyable parts. When we discover the Wizard of O.Z., played wonderfully by Richard Dreyfuss, he is a coked-out sideshow performer. Like tweaked out to the point of incoherence. It is reminiscent of the darkness of Maguire’s book and if expanded could make the series. Also, The Flying Monkeys are actually tattoos on the chest of the wicked sorceress that fly off her skin as she rips off her coat to reveal… well you’ll just have to see. It was a bit of the dark and edgy content that the rest of the show deeply lacked. The Torture of the Tin Man was even resolved in minutes, and it didn’t seem to bother him for the rest of the show. Odd how we forget that so quickly.
Overall, the miniseries falls short of expectations. The concept is there, but I think they need to have a better budget and not worry about pandering to the masses. I was looking for a gritty, harsh OZ with bold mature statements and content. The harsher parts of the series are simply breezed over and almost forgotten. With a few shining points that may make it worth looking up on YouTube, the miniseries generally falls flat. It was watered down and left hinting at where it would like to be if they had a bigger budget… and no censors… and better writers… and a better cast. Okay so it was a sound concept but poorly executed.
Overall grade:
Not worth wasting the time to watch.
Comments
oy...
i watched the whole thing......
6 hours was 2 hours too many. the whole thing felt meandering and convoluted, and seemed more interested in showing off how epic it was trying to be than actually having a good story to tell. i have to agree, if they had better writers (and cut off 2 hours) then it would have been a WHOLE lot better. zooey daschenel is pretty cute though...and richard dreyfuss was great.
Tin Man needs some polish
While I am reluctant to do so, I must say that, overall, I agree with Cheryl. The director of this movie didn't do his job and seemed to be more concerned with the prettiness of pictures (and shooting the "witch's" chest) than with the actual content of the piece. Line delivery even made me, someone who has "Dude, Where's My Car?" on his list of favorite movies, cringe like it was nails on a chalk board. Overall though, it was an interesting story- definitely a new take on the O.Z. Unfortunately, the series tries to set itself up as a sequel to "The Wizard of Oz" which didn't work out...at all. The "C" is definitely well earned. Now Sci-Fi can get back to making b-string monster movies for their Saturday night specials with Adam Baldwin!
I think
I think the miniseries as a whole would have been a lot better if it focused more on the secondary characters, in particular the Tin Man, and Glitch.
Alan Cumming was awesome, he basically stole the show, and the O.Z. could have been a great "character" but they wandered into too many random forests and other rigamaroll. Blah.
I enjoyed it for what it was, but I wouldn't give it any higher than a B- so yeah, Cheryl, good review.